I checked the winning numbers twice because I couldn't believe what I was seeing.
The first time, I thought I must have read something incorrectly.
The second time, my hands began to tremble.
Every number was right.
Every single one.
I sat at our kitchen table with my notebook open in front of me.
For nineteen years, I had written those numbers down.
I knew them without looking.
But that day, I couldn't trust myself to remember anything.
I moved my eyes from the winning results to the notebook.
Then back again.
I counted.
I checked the order.
I looked at each number separately.
Nothing changed.
They matched.
I had won $2.4 million.
Even now, I can remember the strange feeling of seeing that amount connected to something I had bought for two dollars.
It didn't feel like money.
Not at first.
It looked like a figure too large to belong in my life.
I had spent years thinking about ordinary expenses.
Repairs.
Groceries.
The mortgage.
Helping the children when they needed something.
And suddenly, I was looking at enough money to change all of those conversations.
I put one hand against my chest.
My heart was beating so hard that I could feel it beneath my palm.
I didn't jump from my chair.
I didn't shout.
I just sat there.
It was almost too much to take in.
I thought of the roof.
It had needed attention, and every discussion about repairing it had turned into a conversation about what we could afford.
I thought of our old kitchen cabinets.
They had been part of the house for so long that I could hardly picture the room without them.
I thought about how nice it would be to replace things because they needed replacing, rather than waiting until they became impossible to ignore.
Then I thought about the mortgage.
The possibility of no longer owing money on our home seemed almost impossible.
I pictured what that might mean for us.
No more worrying about the same payment month after month.
No more tense conversations whenever a large bill arrived.
Maybe Gary would finally relax.
That thought makes me sad now.
I had just learned that I might be a millionaire, and one of my first hopes was that my husband would become easier to live with.
I didn't think about leaving him.
I thought about making him happy.
I remembered the vacation we had talked about taking for years.
There had always been a reason to postpone it.
Work.
Money.
Some expense that came first.
I imagined telling Gary that we could finally go.
That we could stop saying someday.
I thought of our children too.
They were the reason several of my lottery numbers existed in the first place.
The thought of being able to help them without counting every dollar made my eyes fill.
I knew money wouldn't solve every problem.
But I believed it might remove some of the pressure that had built up in our marriage.
I wanted that so badly.
Not just the financial comfort.
The feeling that Gary and I might have something good to enjoy together again.
For a little while, I let myself imagine it.
Then I remembered the actual ticket.
The notebook showed what I had played.
But the ticket was what mattered.
I needed to see it.
I needed to make certain that I wasn't celebrating something I couldn't prove.
So I got up from the table and went to the refrigerator.
The pineapple magnet was where I had left it.
The ticket wasn't.
I stared at the door.
For a moment, I thought my eyes were playing tricks on me.
Maybe the paper had slipped.
Maybe I hadn't looked carefully.
I touched the magnet and looked around it.
Nothing.
I checked the nearby counter.
No ticket.
I opened the kitchen drawers.
I moved through the papers near the telephone.
I even looked underneath the refrigerator.
There was nothing there either.
I stood back up and looked at the empty space again.
I remembered putting the ticket there.
I remembered signing it first.
I remembered writing the date.
I remembered adding my little sentence.
I remembered the pineapple magnet pressing the paper against the refrigerator.
Those memories were clear.
But I also remembered how certain I had been about the missing envelope years earlier.
And how Gary had convinced me I was mistaken.
The old uncertainty returned almost immediately.
Perhaps I had moved the ticket.
Perhaps I had put it somewhere safer.
Perhaps I had forgotten.
I hated that I went straight to blaming myself.
But I did.
I went through the drawers again.
I looked in places where a lottery ticket had no reason to be.
I was desperate to discover that this was only a foolish mistake.
Then I asked Gary.
"Have you seen the ticket I had on the refrigerator?"
He barely turned his attention toward me.
"What ticket?"
"The lottery ticket. The one under the pineapple."
He didn't seem particularly interested.
He suggested it might have fallen behind the refrigerator.
I told him I had checked there.
He gave a little shrug.
"Well, Patty, you must have put it somewhere."
That was all.
No alarm.
No concern.
No offer to help me search.
I stood there waiting for something more.
We were talking about a ticket that might be worth millions.
Even if he hadn't known it had won, I thought he might have asked why I was so worried.
Instead, he behaved as though I were making a fuss about another misplaced household item.
His calmness should have made me suspicious.
At the time, I let it make me doubt myself.
I returned to the counter.
I opened the drawers yet again.
I looked through my purse.
Then I went into our bedroom and checked the furniture there.
I opened drawers I hadn't used that day.
I searched among papers and things I had put away long before that Friday.
There was no logical reason for the ticket to be in most of those places.
But logic had stopped being useful to me.
I wanted that paper.
I needed it.
I checked the shoebox where I saved my receipts.
It was the same box I had begun using after the money for our daughter's school expenses disappeared.
I had kept those receipts because I never wanted to feel helpless about a missing item again.
Now I was digging through them, hoping I had somehow tucked the ticket inside.
I didn't find it.
I went back to the refrigerator.
The pineapple still hung there.
Bright.
Ordinary.
Almost cheerful.
The sight of it made my stomach hurt.
I had bought that ticket myself.
I knew the numbers.
I knew the day.
I knew where I had placed it.
And yet I was beginning to feel like a woman who couldn't trust her own hands.
I asked Gary once more whether he had seen it.
He said he hadn't.
His answer came easily.
He didn't seem frustrated by my repeated questions.
He simply repeated that he knew nothing about the ticket.
That ordinary tone was convincing.
I had spent most of my adult life hearing Gary speak with confidence.
He could explain something so firmly that I often stopped considering other possibilities.
That day was no different.
I wondered whether I really had misplaced the paper.
Then I wondered whether I had become so excited by the winning numbers that I was remembering the last few days incorrectly.
I tried to think back to Friday.
Carol at the gas station.
The two-dollar purchase.
The drive home.
My signature.
The date.
The sentence beneath it.
The refrigerator.
I could remember every step.
Still, I searched again.
I wasn't ready to consider another explanation.
The idea that Gary might have taken the ticket was so ugly that I kept pushing it away.
This was my husband.
The father of our three children.
The man who had shared my home for decades.
We had argued about money.
He had dismissed me.
He had made me feel small.
But I didn't want to believe he would deliberately take something that belonged to me.
Especially something worth that much.
I told myself that marriage should mean there were certain lines neither person would cross.
I needed that belief.
Without it, I would have to look back at many years of our life and wonder what else I had misunderstood.
So I kept searching.
I didn't celebrate the winning numbers.
I didn't begin making plans.
I didn't picture the roof being repaired or the mortgage disappearing.
The prize had stopped feeling real.
All I could think about was a small piece of paper.
A name written on its back.
A date beneath it.
And a pineapple magnet holding nothing at all.
For nineteen years, I had imagined what winning might feel like.
I thought it would bring relief.
Instead, I was standing in my own kitchen, frightened to ask my husband another question.
The money hadn't changed our lives yet.
But the missing ticket had already changed the way I looked at him.
Click here to continue reading: PART 3: Six Days After My Lottery Ticket Disappeared, Gary Put Divorce Papers on the Table and Told Me I Would Get Almost Nothing
After Thirty-Four Years of Marriage, I Thought I Knew My Husband Until Our Winning Lottery Ticket Vanished From the Refrigerator
Part 2 of 8
