David didn't answer my question immediately.
That was what I remembered most about the conversation.
Not the coffee.
Not the way we were sitting.
The pause.
I had asked whether Chloe ever mentioned me.
He looked uncomfortable.
I could see that he was thinking about how to respond.
Finally, he shook his head.
"Not really."
I looked at him.
"Does she know I ask about her?"
"Yes."
"And she doesn't say anything?"
"She doesn't have much to say."
I tried to accept that.
I really did.
But something inside me was tired of hearing that Chloe wanted nothing to do with me without knowing why.
I folded my hands on the table.
"David, I need you to tell me something."
He looked up.
"What?"
"Did I hurt her?"
He frowned.
"No. You haven't done anything wrong."
I wanted to believe him.
But his answer made the situation harder to understand.
If I had done nothing wrong, why had Chloe disappeared from our lives?
Why would she visit with him but never come to the house?
Why couldn't she send me a simple reply?
I asked him.
"Then what's keeping her away?"
David leaned back.
"It's not as straightforward as you're making it."
I looked at the cup between us.
"I don't think it's straightforward at all. That's why I'm asking."
He rubbed his forehead.
"She's had a difficult time."
I knew what he meant.
Chloe had lost her mother.
No amount of time could make that loss unimportant.
I would never argue otherwise.
But I had been living in the house for years by then.
I was still being treated as someone Chloe couldn't bear to acknowledge.
I wanted to understand how those things were connected.
"Does she think I tried to take her mother's place?"
David shifted in his chair.
"No. It's not exactly that."
"Then what is it?"
He looked away.
And finally, he told me what I would spend the next twelve years believing.
"She feels like I put our marriage ahead of her."
I stared at him.
I had expected him to tell me Chloe was still grieving.
Or that she felt uncomfortable around me.
I had never expected him to say she believed her father had chosen me instead of her.
"She told you that?"
He hesitated.
"That's how she feels."
"But David, her mother had been gone for years before we married."
"I know."
"I never asked you to choose between us."
"I know that too."
I didn't understand.
I kept thinking there must be something else.
Something specific.
Something that had happened when Chloe was seventeen.
"Did she tell you I pushed her out?"
"No. Not in those words."
"Then what words did she use?"
David looked exhausted.
"She needs more time, Alice."
I stared at him.
"How much more?"
He didn't answer.
I remember looking at his face and feeling ashamed for asking.
Maybe he was right.
Maybe I was turning Chloe's grief into a question about my own feelings.
I didn't want to do that.
So I stopped.
I told him I understood.
He reached for his coffee.
The conversation ended.
But the questions didn't.
That night, I lay awake beside David and thought through everything that had happened since I entered their lives.
I remembered our first meals together.
I remembered how careful I had been with the family photographs.
I remembered Chloe's expression the day I moved some of her mother's old magazines.
I had only been trying to straighten the area.
When I noticed that Chloe was upset, I put them back.
At the time, I thought the matter was finished.
Now I wondered whether it had meant something much larger to her.
Maybe she believed I had wanted to clear away her mother's belongings.
Maybe that was why she had never trusted me.
I replayed the scene until I could hardly remember what had actually happened.
That became a habit.
Whenever I remembered something from Chloe's time at home, I would examine it again.
I searched for mistakes.
I searched for words I should have said differently.
I tried to imagine how the same moment might have looked to a seventeen-year-old girl who had already lost one parent.
Perhaps my kindness had felt like an intrusion.
Perhaps my presence had changed the house too quickly.
Perhaps I had been so careful that I seemed cold.
I went around and around with those thoughts.
There was never an answer.
Only another possibility.
The next time I asked David about Chloe, he repeated what he had already told me.
"Give her room to figure things out."
So I did.
I sent fewer messages.
I stopped suggesting she come home for holidays.
I learned not to ask too many questions whenever David returned from seeing her.
I told myself that forcing the issue would only make matters worse.
But I couldn't stop caring about her.
And birthdays were the hardest.
I had always thought birthdays were a simple way to remind someone they mattered.
You didn't need to have a close relationship to wish someone well.
You didn't even need a long conversation.
Sometimes a small gift said enough.
That was how I justified sending the first package.
Chloe was turning eighteen.
I spent a long time choosing what to buy.
I wanted something appropriate for a young woman beginning college.
Something nice, but not too personal.
I finally chose a necklace.
It was delicate and simple.
I could imagine her wearing it without feeling that it carried some large expectation.
At home, I wrapped it carefully.
Then I wrote a birthday card.
I wished her happiness at school.
I told her I hoped she was doing well.
And I signed my name.
I included the word love.
I remember hesitating before writing it.
I didn't know whether Chloe would welcome that.
But I was her stepmother.
I did care about her.
And I thought it would be strange to pretend otherwise.
When I mailed the package, I felt nervous.
I hadn't sent anything like that to her before.
I wondered whether she might call.
Maybe she would send a brief message.
Maybe she would simply open the necklace and think of me for a moment.
That would have been enough.
About two weeks later, the package came back.
I remember seeing it and assuming the postal service had made a mistake.
The box looked exactly as it had when I mailed it.
The wrapping was still neat.
The tape hadn't been disturbed.
I turned it over.
A return label had been attached.
I checked the address carefully.
It was the one David had given me.
I checked again.
Everything seemed correct.
I carried the box inside.
When David came home, I showed it to him.
"Do you know if Chloe changed rooms?"
He looked at the package.
"She might have. College housing can be confusing."
I nodded.
That sounded reasonable.
It was disappointing, but it wasn't necessarily personal.
I put the box away.
I told myself I would try again the following year.
And I did.
For her nineteenth birthday, I chose a scarf.
I spent time considering the color.
I didn't want something too formal.
I didn't want to make another expensive gesture.
I just wanted Chloe to have something useful.
I wrapped it.
I sent it.
Then I waited.
The package returned.
Again, no sign that it had been opened.
I stared at it longer than I had stared at the necklace.
Two mistakes in two years seemed possible.
But I was beginning to feel uneasy.
I didn't ask David very much about the second return.
I didn't want him to think I was trying to create trouble.
I put the scarf with the necklace.
The next year, I bought a book.
I thought a book would be harmless.
There was no reason she had to use it immediately.
She could put it on a shelf.
She could give it away.
She could read it whenever she wanted.
That one came back too.
By then, I had started to dread the sight of a package on the doorstep.
I would notice the familiar size or wrapping before I read the label.
I knew what it meant.
Another birthday had passed.
Another attempt had failed.
I tried to tell myself that Chloe had every right to reject a relationship.
I understood that.
But there was a difference between understanding a person's right to keep their distance and being unaffected by it.
I was affected.
More than I wanted anyone to know.
When Chloe turned twenty-one, I went shopping again.
I found a leather handbag.
It was nicer than the gifts I had sent before.
I stood in the store holding it and wondering whether I was making a mistake.
Twenty-one was an important birthday.
I wanted to mark it.
But I also worried she might see an expensive gift as another attempt to pressure her.
I nearly put it back.
Then I told myself that a birthday gift wasn't a demand.
It was simply a gift.
So I bought it.
I wrapped it carefully.
I checked the address.
I mailed it.
And when the package arrived back at our house, I didn't feel surprised.
I felt foolish.
The box had never been opened.
Not even the tape.
I carried it upstairs without telling David.
That was the first time I deliberately hid a returned gift from him.
I didn't want another conversation about Chloe needing space.
I didn't want to be reminded that she wasn't interested.
I already knew.
At least I thought I did.
After that, the gifts began to collect.
There was the necklace.
The scarf.
The books.
The handbag.
Later, a jewelry box.
A framed print.
Each one had started as a small expression of hope.
Each one ended up stored away.
I didn't use them.
I didn't give them to anyone else.
I couldn't bring myself to throw them out.
Sometimes I would open the closet and see the packages.
I would think about the woman Chloe had become.
I knew she was growing older.
I knew she wasn't the same teenager who had left for college.
But I had no real idea who she was anymore.
David occasionally mentioned a new apartment or something happening at work.
He might mention that she was doing fine.
Those little details were all I had.
I would listen carefully.
Then I would try not to ask for more.
I wanted to know everything.
I wanted to know whether she was happy.
Whether she had friends.
Whether she still baked.
Whether the person she had become might have room for me somewhere in her life.
But David never brought me enough of her world to answer those questions.
One year, when Chloe was turning twenty-five, I was shopping and saw a cookbook.
I stopped walking.
On the cover was a chocolate cake that looked slightly messy.
Not elegant.
Not perfect.
Just the kind of cake someone might make at home.
Immediately, I remembered that rainy Saturday.
Chloe standing in the kitchen.
Flour on the counter.
The collapsed cake.
Her laughter.
I stood there holding the cookbook and felt something I hadn't felt in a long time.
Hope.
Not much.
Just enough to make me buy it.
This gift felt different.
The necklace had been something I thought a young woman might like.
The scarf had been practical.
The handbag had been a birthday present chosen with care.
But the cookbook came from a memory we had shared.
A real memory.
I knew Chloe had been there.
I knew she had laughed.
I knew that afternoon had happened.
For once, I wasn't guessing about what she might enjoy.
I was remembering something she had actually loved doing.
At home, I wrote a longer card.
I mentioned the cake.
I told her the book had reminded me of the times she baked.
I said I hoped baking still brought her comfort.
Then I reached the end.
I almost signed it with love.
My pen stopped.
After all those returned packages, the word suddenly felt too heavy.
I wondered whether Chloe disliked seeing it.
Maybe she thought I was claiming feelings she didn't share.
Maybe even the word love made her feel obligated.
So I changed it.
I signed the card with a simple message that I was thinking of her.
Then I mailed the cookbook.
For several days, I tried not to imagine what might happen.
But I couldn't help it.
I pictured her opening the box.
I pictured her seeing the cake on the cover.
I wondered whether she would remember that Saturday as clearly as I did.
I wondered whether she might smile.
That was all I wanted.
One small reminder that we had once shared something good.
Then the package came back.
I recognized it immediately.
I carried it upstairs.
I sat on the floor beside it.
For a while, I just looked at the cardboard.
I knew the cookbook was inside.
I knew the card was still there.
I knew the message had never been read.
And for the first time, I cried.
Not because the gift had been expensive.
Not because I expected thanks.
I cried because I had spent years holding onto a memory that apparently meant nothing to the person who shared it with me.
I covered my face.
I tried to stop.
Then David came into the room.
He saw me sitting there.
He saw the package.
And when he spoke, there was something in his voice that made me feel even smaller.
"Alice, you can't keep doing this to yourself."
I looked up at him.
I thought he was going to comfort me.
Instead, he was about to tell me something I would remember every time Chloe's birthday came around.
Click here to continue reading: PART 3: After Twelve Unopened Birthday Gifts, I Finally Decided to Leave My Stepdaughter Alone, but Three Days Later Something Unexpected Arrived at My Door
I Thought My Stepdaughter Needed Time to Accept Me, but the First Years of Our Marriage Left Me Questioning Everything I Did
Part 2 of 12
